Last updated on October 4, 2025
Join our WhatsApp community and be part of the conversation!
Critics have pointed to Amorim’s tactical approach as a core issue.
Image credit: Arsenal Rep
Rúben Amorim’s time as Manchester United manager has been anything but smooth.
What started as a promising appointment has gradually turned into a period marked by missed opportunities, tactical missteps, and mounting criticism from fans and pundits alike.
Missed Opportunities and Tactical Setbacks
Amorim had an early chance to make a strong impression with a 2-1 victory over Chelsea.
On paper, it seemed like the perfect momentum-builder. Yet, he failed to capitalize on this win.
💥 Love the Premier League? Stay Ahead of the Game – Join the Ultimate EPL Fan Newsletter!
In the very next match against Brentford, United suffered a 3-1 defeat, with Amorim admitting afterward that his team played exactly as Brentford had planned.
This result extended Manchester United’s winless away run in the Premier League to eight games, highlighting the team’s ongoing struggle with consistency.
Critics have pointed to Amorim’s tactical approach as a core issue.
His system, often described as ill-suited to the pace and physicality of the Premier League, has left players struggling to adapt.
The result is a lack of cohesion on the pitch, frequent underperformance, and a team that appears to falter under pressure.
Challenges with Player Management
Amorim’s approach to managing his squad has also come under scrutiny.
Alejandro Garnacho, a young talent previously part of the so-called “bomb squad,” was at one point isolated from the first team and forced to train alone—a period he described as a “bad moment in life.”
After a £40 million move to Chelsea, Garnacho has slowly worked his way back into competitive action, making his first start in a Carabao Cup match and contributing to a crucial Champions League victory over Benfica.
Similarly, Tyrell Malacia, another player initially excluded from the first team, has recently rejoined the squad after impressing in training.
These examples suggest Amorim may be adjusting his approach to player management, though inconsistency remains a concern.
Fan Sentiment and the Question of the Future
Fan sentiment has become increasingly critical.
On forums like Reddit, supporters are openly questioning the direction of the team under Amorim’s guidance.
Inconsistent performances and a failure to build on positive results have eroded confidence, leaving many uncertain whether he can steer Manchester United back to its former glory.
Financial considerations may be delaying decisive action from the club.
Sacking Amorim before the one-year mark of his appointment could trigger a substantial compensation package, adding complexity to the decision.
Nonetheless, reports indicate that several potential replacements—including Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler, Crystal Palace’s Oliver Glasner, and Bournemouth’s Andoni Iraola—are being considered.
Gareth Southgate is also rumored to be on the radar.
Internally, Amorim still retains some support, particularly from co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who reportedly wants to give him a full season to prove himself.
However, low morale within the squad and growing external pressure make his position increasingly precarious.
Conclusion
Rúben Amorim’s tenure at Manchester United has so far been defined by missed opportunities, tactical challenges, and questions around player management.
